Story Stocks^®

With the news flow light today, we're highlighting a high-ranking member of our YIELD Leaders list: MGIC Investment (MTG), a leading provider of private mortgage insurance (PMI) and other mortgage credit risk products. With U.S. mortgage rates pulling back from last summer's highs—and the Fed expected (but not guaranteed) to cut rates by 25 bps on December 10—this is a timely moment to revisit the name.

A Direct Play on Housing Market Dynamics

• MTG's business is tightly linked to the housing market. PMI is typically required when a buyer puts down less than 20%—a situation increasingly common as home prices rise and affordability remains stretched.
• On its Q3 call, MTG noted early signs of improvement: Easing mortgage rates and slower home price appreciation are modestly lifting affordability. Housing inventory, while still tight, has improved since last year. Purchase applications continue to show a slow-but-steady upward trend.

Large Capital Returns Stand Out

• MTG maintains a top spot in our YIELD rankings largely due to aggressive share repurchases, signaling management confidence. In Q3, MTG bought back 7 mln shares for $188 mln. Over the past four quarters, total buybacks reached $786 mln.
• With a $6.3 bln market cap, these repurchases are highly meaningful, supporting a robust 12.1% buyback yield. Management reiterated that share repurchases will remain the primary method of returning capital to shareholders.

Affordability Issues Actually Support MTG

• While affordability challenges might normally suggest caution toward housing-linked stocks, in MTG's case the dynamic can be beneficial.
• When buyers can't reach the 20% down payment threshold, PMI becomes a requirement—directly boosting demand for MTG's products. Lower mortgage rates could further support homebuyer activity, even if affordability remains strained.
• A Watch Item: Account-based delinquency rate rose 11 bps in Q3 to 2.32%, matching internal expectations. New delinquency notices were slightly lower yr/yr, and remain low by historical standards. Going forward, MTG expects seasonality and the aging of its 2021-22 books to push delinquency notices and the delinquency rate higher. While manageable for now, this remains an area to monitor.

Briefing.com Analyst Insight

MTG stands out because of the magnitude and consistency of its buybacks. That activity—coupled with a gradually rising share price—signals solid management conviction in near-term fundamentals. While the delinquency rate is inching higher, the increases are modest and well telegraphed. The more important macro lever is mortgage rates: if the Fed does cut in December and rates continue to drift lower, MTG should see incremental demand tailwinds in 2025-26. Crucially, affordability challenges don't undermine MTG—they reinforce the need for PMI, making MTG a rare name that benefits from an otherwise strained housing backdrop. Given its capital return profile and favorable structural setup, MTG is worth keeping on the radar for yield-focused investors.